Skip to content

Español
List your Rental

Español
List your Rental
Top 10 Carthage Houses
Modern Renter Blog
Apartments for Rent
Houses for Rent
Condos for Rent
Townhomes for Rent

Submit feedback

Search by Location

Search by Location

< $2,500

Beds & Baths

Pets

Filter Your Search

All Filters

Rent Range

Minimum Rent-

Beds

Any
Studio
1
2
3
4+

Baths

Any
1+
2+
3+

Type

Apartments
Condos
Houses
Townhomes
Rentals

Styles

Cheap
Duplex
Lofts
Luxury
Mother In Law Suite
Penthouse
Smart
Waterfront
High Rise
Mid Rise
Low Rise

Amenities

Air Conditioning
Furnished
Garages
Patio or Balcony
Pool
Storage Space
Utilities Included
Washer & Dryer
Wheelchair Access
Yard
Dog Park
Dishwasher
Elevator
EV Charging
Fireplace
Fitness Center
Gated
Hardwood Floors
High Ceilings
Laundry Facility
Laundry Hookup
Walk-in Closets

Pets

Any
Dogs
Cats
Pet Friendly
None

Specialties

All
Student
Senior
Military
Corporate
None

More Options

Short Term Lease
Income Restricted
For Rent by Owner
Rooms for Rent
Move-in Specials

Houses for Rent under $2,500 in Carthage, IN

1,743 Houses Available

Sort

Default

Lowest Price

Highest Price

Newest Listings

Filter Your Search

1 Day Ago
3862 Dusty Sands Rd, Whitestown, IN 46075
3 Beds $2,295
Call(463) 205-0614
1 Day Ago
6037 E 43rd St, Indianapolis, IN 46226
3 Beds $1,400
1 Day Ago
1217 N Rural St, Indianapolis, IN 46201
3 Beds $1,100
Call(317) 210-3637
1 Day Ago
10243 Cumberland Pointe Blvd, Noblesville, IN 46060
3 Beds $1,915
Call(463) 209-8882
1 Wk Ago
3110 S Pershing Dr, Muncie, IN 47302
3 Beds $1,250
1 Day Ago
321 E 31st St, Indianapolis, IN 46205
3 Beds $1,295
Call(317) 842-3400
1 Day Ago
11256 Harrington Ln, Fishers, IN 46038
3 Beds $2,195
Call(463) 231-3219
2 Wks Ago
611 S Harrison St, Alexandria, IN 46001
3 Beds $1,550
1 Day Ago
1853 Montcalm St, Indianapolis, IN 46202
3 Beds $1,800
Call(317) 710-9743
1 Day Ago
906 Brookstone Dr, Franklin, IN 46131
3 Beds $1,580
Call(317) 854-5422
3 Days Ago
865 W 136th St, Carmel, IN 46032
3 Beds $2,000
1 Day Ago
1910 Southeastern Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46201
1 Bed $875
Call(317) 210-3637
1 Day Ago
14182 Calming Waters, Fishers, IN 46038
3 Beds $2,280
Call(463) 231-3914
2 Wks Ago
1238 S State Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203 Unit Apt 2
1 Bed $1,500
1 Day Ago
1702 E 25th St, Indianapolis, IN 46218
2 Beds $850
Call(317) 210-3637
1 Day Ago
8243 Retreat Ln, Indianapolis, IN 46259
3 Beds $2,345
Call(463) 219-2964
2 Days Ago
3360 Ransdell St, Indianapolis, IN 46227 Unit B 2 bd
2 Beds $2,200
1 Day Ago
2005 Hoyt Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203
3 Beds $2,450
Call(574) 606-0299
1 Day Ago
10604 Magenta Dr, Noblesville, IN 46060
4 Beds $2,340
Call(317) 854-5882
1 Wk Ago
5860 Primrose Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220
3 Beds $2,500
1 Day Ago
1534 Dawson St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
3 Beds $1,350
Call(317) 210-3637
1 Day Ago
511 Zephyr Way, Westfield, IN 46074
3 Beds $1,885
Call(463) 230-6284
6 Days Ago
607 S Georgia St, Sheridan, IN 46069
3 Beds $1,500
1 Day Ago
1940 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
1 Bed $825
Call(317) 210-3637
1 Day Ago
389 Longview Bnd, Brownsburg, IN 46112
3 Beds $2,075
Call(463) 231-4020
6 Days Ago
8342 Stark Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46216
3 Beds $2,250
1 Day Ago
2106 Singleton St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
2 Beds $995
Call(317) 210-3637
1 Day Ago
5363 Rolling River Ct, Indianapolis, IN 46221
4 Beds $1,930
Call(463) 209-7114
2 Wks Ago
317 West Dr, Connersville, IN 47331
2 Beds $1,325
1 Day Ago
4 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
1 Bed $620
Call(317) 210-3637
1 Day Ago
6546 Shanghai Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46278
3 Beds $2,025
Call(317) 793-2426
1 Wk Ago
1835 Carpenter Cir, Indianapolis, IN 46203
3 Beds $2,110
1 Day Ago
1948 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
1 Bed $875
Call(317) 210-3637
1 Day Ago
4167 Ash Lawn Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46234
3 Beds $1,820
Call(317) 779-2698
2 Wks Ago
4625 Rookwood Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46208
3 Beds $2,100
1 Day Ago
4131 Robertson Ct, Indianapolis, IN 46228
3 Beds $2,215
Call(463) 300-6856
1 Day Ago
10201 Stillwell Dr, Avon, IN 46123
3 Beds $1,935
Call(463) 666-3004
1 Wk Ago
4916 Mecca St, Indianapolis, IN 46241
3 Beds $1,900
1 Day Ago
2002 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
2 Beds $900
Call(317) 210-3637
1 Day Ago
10395 Butler Dr, Brownsburg, IN 46112
3 Beds $2,415
Call(463) 777-2661

page 1
page 2
page 3
page 4
page 5
page 6
page 7
page 8

ForRent
IN
Carthage Houses

Follow us on

Facebook

© 2025 CoStar Group

Site Links and Information

Resources

Customer Portal
Add a Listing
Rental Calculator
Apartment Living Blog

Rental Manager

List property for rent
Collect rent payments
Create/Generate rental leases
Screen tenants
Manage rental maintenance requests
Rental expense tracking

Marketplace

ApartmentHomeLiving.com
WestsideRentals.com
After55.com
ForRentUniversity.com
CorporateHousing.com

About Us

Contact Us
About Us
Accessibility
Terms of Service
Privacy Notice
Fraud Prevention
Avoid Scams
CA: Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Sitemap

Follow us on

Facebook

© 2025 CoStar Group

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All measurements are approximate.

Equal Opportunity Housing