Houses for Rent in Amityville, NY

Known for its waterfront beauty and the historic 1760s-era Amityville Village Triangle, Amityville combines maritime heritage with small-town charm along Long Island's South Shore. This waterfront village, just 40 miles from Manhattan, offers a relaxed coastal lifestyle with average rental home prices ranging from $2,700 for single-bedroom properties to $3,800 for three-bedroom houses. The downtown district near The Triangle, where Broadway and Park Avenue meet, features local dining spots and boutique shopping, while the nearby Amityville Beach provides scenic waterfront recreation. Residents appreciate the village's strategic location, with the Amityville LIRR station offering direct service to Penn Station and multiple bus routes connecting throughout Long Island. The area includes the historic district near Park Avenue, showcasing preserved Victorian-era architecture, and the waterfront neighborhood south of Merrick Road, characterized by its coastal properties and water views. Amityville's location offers convenient access to both Nassau and Suffolk Counties, making it an ideal spot for those seeking a balance of suburban living and city accessibility.