Houses for Rent in Carle Place, NY

A historic Long Island community that grew from William Levitt's innovative post-WWII housing development, Carle Place offers a peaceful suburban setting just minutes from New York City. Houses for rent in this compact Nassau County hamlet provide residents with established neighborhoods and excellent transportation options. The Long Island Rail Road's Carle Place station serves as a central hub, offering regular 45-minute trains to Manhattan. The area surrounding Cherry Lane features tree-lined residential streets with well-maintained rental homes, while the neighborhoods near Old Country Road connect to shopping districts and local amenities. At just one square mile, Carle Place puts residents within easy reach of employment centers in Garden City and Mineola, with convenient access to major parkways. Bordered by the established communities of Garden City, Mineola, and Westbury, this centrally located hamlet combines accessibility with residential charm, all while maintaining its distinct small-town character.