Houses for Rent in Atlantic Highlands, NJ

Perched atop the highest natural elevation on the Atlantic seaboard south of Maine, Atlantic Highlands offers spectacular Manhattan skyline views from its 266-foot elevation above sea level. This historic borough combines small-town charm with exceptional commuting convenience via the SeaStreak ferry service, which provides direct access to Manhattan's financial district and East 34th Street in under an hour. The established neighborhoods near First Avenue showcase well-maintained rental houses with architectural character, while the elevated areas around Mount Mitchill feature homes with sweeping bay views. The downtown district along First Avenue presents a variety of local restaurants and independent boutiques, while the municipal harbor — the largest on the East Coast — serves as a hub for boating enthusiasts. The ferry terminal provides convenient Manhattan commutes, and Route 36 offers quick access to regional business centers. The borough's cultural scene includes the First Avenue Playhouse, art galleries, and waterfront dining establishments, while the extensive park system, including the scenic Henry Hudson Trail and Mount Mitchill Scenic Overlook, provides abundant outdoor recreation opportunities. With average rental rates ranging from $2,300 for smaller properties to $3,200+ for larger houses, Atlantic Highlands delivers a coastal living experience that combines historic charm with modern convenience.