Houses for Rent in Middle Island, NY

Known for its abundant natural spaces and golf courses, Middle Island, NY sits halfway between the East River and Montauk Point. This established Long Island community, spanning just over 8 square miles, features three golf courses and two nature preserves - Cathedral Pines County Park and Prosser Pines Nature Preserve. The rental market shows steady growth, with three-bedroom homes averaging $3,877 monthly. Popular rental locations near Artist Lake and Pine Lake provide scenic views and convenient access to the Longwood Public Library and shopping along Middle Country Road. The hamlet's strategic position offers manageable commutes to major employment centers, with the Long Island Expressway and Port Jefferson Station both within easy reach. Neighborhoods around Spring Lake and along Middle Island-Miller Place Road offer proximity to pristine parklands and essential amenities. Middle Island combines spacious rental homes with the tranquility of suburban living, all while maintaining easy access to Long Island's major destinations.