Skip to content
  • Photo - Mid Island Apartments

Mid Island Apartments

35 Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Floor Plan Summary
Monthly Rent Bedrooms Bathrooms
$2,150 - $3,080 Studio - 2 1 - 1.5
View Fees and Policies

Pricing and Floor Plans

Rent Estimate
Cost Calculator: Estimate your monthly and one-time fees.

S1

$2,150 - $2,205
Studio, 1 Bath
400 Sq. Ft.

Show Floor Plan Details

3 Rentals Available
Unit
Price
Sq. Ft.
Available
0751C
$2,150
400
Now
0652C
$2,205
400
6/27/26
0531D
$2,150
400
7/6/26

A2

$2,575 - $2,690
1 Bed, 1 Bath
705 Sq. Ft.

Show Floor Plan Details

2 Rentals Available
Unit
Price
Sq. Ft.
Available
0591A
$2,690
705
Now
0612D
$2,575
705
7/9/26

A1

$2,430 - $2,570
1 Bed, 1 Bath
665 Sq. Ft.

Show Floor Plan Details

Jun. 1
Unit
Price
Sq. Ft.
Available
0091A
$2,570
665
6/1/26
0272D
$2,430
665
6/21/26

B4

$2,950 - $3,080
2 Beds, 1.5 Baths
875 Sq. Ft.

Show Floor Plan Details

2 Rentals Available
Unit
Price
Sq. Ft.
Available
0172C
$2,950
875
Now
0231B
$3,080
875
7/10/26

B5

$2,940
2 Beds, 1 Bath
915 Sq. Ft.

Show Floor Plan Details

1 Rental Available
Unit
Price
Sq. Ft.
Available
0572C
$2,940
915
Now

B1

$2,935
2 Beds, 1 Bath
820 Sq. Ft.

Show Floor Plan Details

Jun. 1
Unit
Price
Sq. Ft.
Available
0112B
$2,935
820
6/1/26
* Price shown is total price based on community-supplied monthly required fees. Excludes user-selected optional fees and variable or usage-based fees and required charges due at or prior to move-in or at move-out. View Fees and Policies for details. Price, availability, fees, and any applicable rent special are subject to change without notice. * Square footage definitions vary. Displayed square footage is approximate.

Details

Lease Term Options

  • 12 mo

Property Information

  • Built in 1965
  • 232 units / 2 stories

Fees and Policies

The fees below are based on community-supplied data and may exclude additional fees and utilities.

Utilities & Essentials

  • Utility - Billing Administrative Fee
    $5 / mo

One-Time Basics

Due at Application

  • Application Fee (Per Applicant)
    $20

Due at Move-In

  • Utility - Setup Fee
    $10
  • Replacement - Mailbox Key
    $50
  • Replacement - Access Device
    $50

Property Fee Disclaimer Based on community-supplied data and independent market research. Subject to change without notice. May exclude fees for mandatory or optional services and usage-based utilities.

Matterport 3D Tours

Explore Commute Options

Destination Address
  • Drive Time
    --
  • Walk Time
    --
  • Bike Ride Time
    --
  • Public Transit
    --

Property Highlights

  • Air Conditioner
  • Dishwasher
  • High or Vaulted Ceilings in Select Apartments
  • Microwave
  • Newly Renovated Apartment Homes
  • Newly Renovated Apartment Homes (In Select Apartment Homes)
  • Open Lot Parking
  • Stainless Steel Appliances
  • Stainless Steel Appliances (In Select Apartment Homes)
  • Thermal-pane Windows in Select Apartments

Apartment Features

  • Air Conditioning
  • Ceiling Fans
  • Dishwasher
  • Hardwood Floors
  • Heating
  • High Speed Internet Access
  • Microwave
  • Range
  • Refrigerator
  • Stainless Steel Appliances

Community Features

  • Playground
  • Walk-Up

Map of Mid Island Apartments

Loading...

Area Scores

Walkability

Moderately walkable60 / 100

Transit

Limited public transit30 / 100

Driveability

Moderately drivable70 / 100

Bikeability

Somewhat bikeable30 / 100

Scores provided by

Transit

Commuter Rail
3 min Drive
Long Island Rail Road
Commuter Rail
4 min Drive
Long Island Rail Road
Airport
Long Island MacArthur
19 min Drive
Long Island MacArthur
Airport
John F Kennedy International
46 min Drive
John F. Kennedy International

Moving to Downtown Bay Shore, Bay Shore, NY

Shopping Centers

Shoppers will appreciate Mid Island Apartments proximity to Saxon Commons, South Shore Plaza, and 76-90 Park Ave. Saxon Commons is 0.6 miles away, and South Shore Plaza is within a 16 minute walk.

Commuting

With a TransitScore of 30, Mid Island Apartments has limited public transit, including 5 transit stops within 6.2 miles. Transit options include Bay Shore Station and Islip Station.

Parks and Recreation

Recreational activities near Mid Island Apartments are plentiful. Discover 2 parks within 4.3 miles, including Gardiner County Park and Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park.

Airports

Living in Downtown Bay Shore provides easy access to Long Island MacArthur, located just 19 minutes from Mid Island Apartments. Another nearby airport is John F Kennedy International, located 33.5 miles away.

Local Education

Primary and Secondary Schools

undefined rating

Brook Avenue Elementary School

Grades K-5

Public

4 rating

Gardiner Manor School

Grades K-5

Public

5 rating

Bay Shore Middle School

Grades 6-8

Public

undefined rating

St Patrick School

Grades PK-8

Private

7 rating

Islip High School

Grades 9-12

Public

6 rating

Bay Shore Senior High School

Grades 9-12

Public

undefined rating

MDQ Academy

Grades PK-12

Private

Data provided by GreatSchools.org © 2026. All rights reserved.

GreatSchools Logo

Colleges and Universities

School

Commute Time (Distance)

Touro University

Drive: 9 min (4.9 mi)

SUNY Suffolk Co., Grant Campus

Drive: 14 min (7.9 mi)

St Joseph's Coll., Long Island

Drive: 20 min (12.6 mi)

Farmingdale State College

Drive: 23 min (14.2 mi)

About Mid Island Apartments

Mid Island Apartments is more than just a place to call home. Our quality studio, one, and two-bedroom apartment homes have been upgraded to match your lifestyle. This quaint community, built with traditional brick architecture, is surrounded by... expansive green courtyards and tucked into the historic Bay Shore neighborhood on Long Island, New York. Our recently remodeled, pet-friendly homes feature hardwood flooring, and stainless-steel appliances. Enticing outdoor adventure, delicious dining options, charming coffee shops, and highly rated schools are just minutes from Mid Island Apartments.

Mid Island Apartments is an apartment community in Bay Shore, NY

Eagle Rock Properties

Contact

Property Address:
35 Penataquit Ave,
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Phone Number: (631) 894-9778
More Information:
View Property Website
Office Hours
  • SundayCLOSED
  • Monday9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
  • Tuesday9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
  • Wednesday9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
  • Thursday9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
  • Friday9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
  • Saturday9:00 AM - 5:30 PM

Renter Reviews

For Mid Island Apartments

4.9

2 Ratings & Reviews

How Is This Rating Determined?

3/25/24

Just don’t live here.

I regret to say that my experience living at this apartment complex has been thoroughly disappointing. The incessant noise from neighbors makes it nearly impossible to relax or concentrate. Additionally, the lack of consistent hot water is unacceptable and makes daily routines uncomfortable. Despite numerous attempts to contact the leasing office about these issues, their lack of responsiveness only adds to the frustration. Overall, I cannot recommend this apartment complex to anyone seeking a... peaceful and comfortable living environment.

Review from Apartments.com

8 People Found This Helpful

Was this helpful?

Property Manager at Mid Island Apartments responded to this review

Afton D.,

Thank you for sharing your feedback with us. We sincerely apologize for the disappointing experience you've had during your time at our apartment complex.

We understand the frustrations with the ongoing water issue. Our team has been...
actively working to resolve the hot water issue, and while temporary solutions have been implemented, we are working towards a permanent solution. We are committed to continuing our efforts until this issue is fully resolved.

Regarding noise disturbances, we understand how disruptive this can be to your daily life. While we don't have any notes in your tenant history regarding noise complaints, we take your feedback seriously and will take additional steps to address this matter promptly.

We apologize if there have been any lapses in responsiveness from our leasing office. We strive to provide excellent customer service to all our residents, and we regret any instances where we may have fallen short. Your satisfaction is important to us, and we would appreciate the opportunity to discuss your concerns further and work towards finding solutions. Please feel free to reach out to us directly so that we can assist you in any way possible.

9/18/20

Excited!

Couldn't be happier with Mark! Moving in soon....he made himself available quickly & answered all my questions. Apartment finishes are gorgeous! Will review again after I move in

Review from Apartments.com

17 People Found This Helpful

Was this helpful?

Property Manager at Mid Island Apartments responded to this review

Dear Valued Resident, we're glad you had such a wonderful experience with our Property Manager, Mark! Our team strives to deliver an excellent experience, and are glad you found this to be the case during your visit. If you have further needs or... questions, please reach out!
All our best,
Mid Island Apartments

Mid Island Apartments Gallery

Nearby Properties You Might Like

Within 50 Miles of Mid Island Apartments

Find More Rentals in Bay Shore

Find More Rentals Nearby…

Call