139 Northside Dr, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Also Available: May 23rd - Jun 30th $35K, Jan 1st - May 23rd 35K

A gated, private entrance leads to this well-appointed 5 bedroom home with 2 primary suites.... The home is set on a gorgeous 1.3 acre property, with grounds that impress all. A fully renovated, newly furnished interior features a double height living room with fireplace, open kitchen, dining room with private courtyard and new gym! One of the two primary suites is on the first floor. There is a second primary with large balcony upstairs, plus 2 additional generous bedrooms. Conducive for working or learning from home, the owners built out an office and reading nooks and detailed carpentry. A newly finished lower level has a TV room with large screen TV and 5th bedroom. An attached garage with bikes is an added bonus for exploring this quiet neighborhood. Completing the estate-like setting, there is over 2000 square feet of decking and an impressive Tortorella-designed gunite pool with waterfall. Located in prestigious Northside Hills, within the coveted Sag Harbor School district. [[Rental Registration # RP231033 - 10/03/2025]]
EH RR #: RP231033

Rental Terms:
October: $10,000
Other / Short Term - Year Round: $180,000
July - Labor Day: $125,000
April: $10,000
September/October: $27,500
May: $15,000
July: $60,000
March: $9,000
June: $35,000
January: $9,000
August - Labor Day: $65,000
Memorial Day - Labor Day: $150,000
February: $9,000
August: $60,000
November: $9,000 Read More