7/29/26
All are welcome!
Living at Allen Bay has been phenomenal, especially because of my neighbors and the management team. The property manager has made moving in so much easier and I feel quite welcome here!
Review from Apartments.com

2152 Middleton Beach Rd, Middleton, WI 53562
Managed By

| Bedrooms | Bathrooms | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $1,800 - $3,750 | 1 - 3 Beds | 1 - 3 | 1 - 2 Baths | 1 - 2 | 713 - 1,769 sq. ft. |
| 12 Month Lease |
Show Floor Plan Details
Show Floor Plan Details
Show Floor Plan Details
Show Floor Plan Details
Show Floor Plan Details
Show Floor Plan Details
Show Floor Plan Details
Show Floor Plan Details
Show Floor Plan Details
Show Floor Plan Details
Show Floor Plan Details
Show Floor Plan Details
Show Floor Plan Details
Show Floor Plan Details
Lease Term Options
Property Information
The fees below are based on community-supplied data and may exclude additional fees and utilities.
Max of 1
Property Fee Disclaimer Based on community-supplied data and independent market research. Subject to change without notice. May exclude fees for mandatory or optional services and usage-based utilities.
Walkability
Somewhat walkable30 / 100
Driveability
Exceptionally drivable100 / 100
Bikeability
Very bikeable80 / 100

Shoppers will appreciate Allen Bay proximity to Park Wood Plaza and Middleton Hills. Park Wood Plaza is 1.1 miles away, and Middleton Hills is within a 27 minute walk.
Recreational activities near Allen Bay are plentiful. Discover 3 parks within 4.5 miles, including Stricker's Pond, Owen Conservation Park, and Governor Nelson State Park.
Living in Springs provides easy access to Dane County Regional/Truax Field, located just 21 minutes from Allen Bay.
Sauk Trail Elementary School
Grades PK-5
Public
Spring Harbor Middle
Grades 6-8
Public
Kromrey Middle School
Grades K-8
Public
Peace Thru Christ Lutheran School
Grades K-8
Private
Lighthouse Christian School
Grades PK-8
Private
Clark Street Community School
Grades 9-12
Public
Horizon High
Grades 9-12
Private
Middleton High School
Grades 9-12
Public
Data provided by GreatSchools.org © 2026. All rights reserved.
School
Commute Time (Distance)
University of Wisconsin
Drive: 11 min (4.4 mi)
Edgewood University
Drive: 14 min (5.4 mi)
Madison Area Technical College
Drive: 23 min (11.9 mi)
Lake where you live.
Welcome to Allen Bay, located just steps from Lake Mendota. Two intimate 31-residence buildings offer thoughtfully designed one-bedroom apartments, spacious two-bedrooms, and elegant three-bedroom townhomes.
Gather with... friends in the inviting club room, stay active in the fully equipped fitness center, and unwind on the lakeview deck. Step outside to parks, boating access, and the shores of Lake Mendota, all just minutes from downtown Madison and Middleton. Every day feels like a getaway.
One complimentary interior parking space is included within your rental rate.
Lake where you live.
Welcome to Allen Bay, located just steps from Lake Mendota. Two intimate 31-residence buildings offer thoughtfully designed one-bedroom apartments, spacious two-bedrooms, and elegant three-bedroom townhomes.
Gather with friends in the inviting club room, stay active in the fully equipped fitness center, and unwind on the lakeview deck. Step outside to parks, boating access, and the shores of Lake Mendota, all just minutes from downtown Madison and Middleton. Every day feels like a getaway.
One complimentary interior parking space is included within your rental rate.
Allen Bay is an apartment community in Middleton, WI


For Allen Bay
2.9
6 Ratings & Reviews
7/29/26
Living at Allen Bay has been phenomenal, especially because of my neighbors and the management team. The property manager has made moving in so much easier and I feel quite welcome here!
Review from Apartments.com
7/28/26
Way overpriced for not even being on the lake. In fact, not even a view of the lake! The “lake access” is a public park down the street that literally everyone has access to so why would I pay a premium for that? Like another reviewer said, they advertise that it is waterfront and technically it is… it is on a retention pond that the tour guide kept boasting about. A tiny pond that was dried up a few days after I toured. It is brand new construction so at least it’s not rundown and dated (hence... an extra star rating) but still very overpriced and false advertising.
Review from Apartments.com
2 People Found This Helpful
6/29/26
I drove a long way to tour these apartments, and that's on me because I apparently I should've looked on a map instead of believing the listing. (For the record, per merriam webster, "waterfront" describes property where the land directly touches the water, distinguishing it from a "waterview" (which simply means you can see the water). I did a showing nonetheless since I was already here, and these are quite overpriced for what they offer, in my opinion. They offered a free month rent, but even... with that, still too $$$ for what they are.
Review from Apartments.com
2 People Found This Helpful
Property Manager at Allen Bay responded to this review
Thank you for taking the time to visit Allen Bay and share your feedback. We're sorry the location did not align with what you expected, and we appreciate you bringing that concern to our attention.
Our pricing reflects the community's brand-new... apartment homes, premium finishes, complimentary garage parking, boutique setting, and a location just steps from Lake Mendota and Marshall Park. We appreciate you touring with us and wish you the best in finding a home that is the right fit.
5/12/26
I toured, and for the price point, finishes seem very cheap - especially the cabinets. These are priced as very high-end, I guess because they are near the lake. However they are not "waterfront" as advertised, and only a select few units even have a view of the water. The "lake access" is at an adjacent public park, not at all affiliated with this apartment complex. Also - no matter what size apartment you rent, you only get one parking spot, and there is very little street parking. Should you... want to park in the few surface spots affiliated with the apartments, you will then need to walk all the way to one end of the building to gain entry. There are no entry doors on the parking lot side of the building. Not great for hauling in groceries, especially in inclement weather. And not much space for guests to park at all. On top of all this, they will soon be starting on two more 5-6 story buildings in the field right next to these, which is great for those who love the sound of construction for the next two years! For these reasons, I am a hard pass on these apartments.
Review from Apartments.com
6 People Found This Helpful
3/12/26
Their leasing team has been so helpful and kind so far! Looking forward to making Allen Bay my home.
Review from Apartments.com
Within 50 Miles of Allen Bay
Tour Options:
In-Person
Languages: English
Closed Today