Bay Colony I

189 E Fairmount Ave, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

Last Updated: 1 Day Ago
(1)
Monthly Rent
$965
View Fees and Policies
Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
1 Bath
Sq. Ft.
850 sq ft

Pricing and Floor Plans

Cost Calculator: Estimate your monthly and one-time fees.

2bd

$965
2 Beds, 1 Bath
850 Sq. Ft.
Show Floor Plan Details
1 Available Unit
Unit
Price
Sq. Ft.
Available
201-03
$965
850
Nov. 12
* Price shown is base rent. Excludes user-selected optional fees and variable or usage-based fees and required charges due at or prior to move-in or at move-out. Price, availability, fees, and any applicable rent special are subject to change without notice. * Square footage definitions vary. Displayed square footage is approximate.

Details

Lease Term Options

  • 12 mo

Property Information

  • Built in 1949
  • 32 units2 stories

Fees & Policies

The fees below are based on community-supplied data and may exclude additional fees and utilities.

One-Time Basics

Due at Application

  • Application Fee Per Applicant
    $35

Property Fee Disclaimer: Based on community-supplied data and independent market research. Subject to change without notice. May exclude fees for mandatory or optional services and usage-based utilities.

Explore Commute Options

Drive Time
Walk Time
Bike Ride Time
Public Transit

Property Highlights

  • Coin Operating Washer/Dryer
  • Heat Included
  • Off Street Parking

Community Features

  • Maintenance on site
  • Walk-Up

Map of Bay Colony I

Area Scores

Walkability

Moderately walkable

Transit

Some public transit

Driveability

Very drivable

Bikeability

Exceptionally bikeable

Scores provided by

Soundscore

Active

Scores provided by

Transit

Commuter Rail

14 min Drive

Amtrak

Airport

General Mitchell International

25 min Drive

General Mitchell International

Moving to Shorewood/Whitefish Bay, Whitefish Bay, WI

Shopping Centers

Shoppers will appreciate Bay Colony I proximity to Fast Signs Retail Plaza. Fast Signs Retail Plaza is 0.9 miles away.

Commuting

With a TransitScore of 40, Bay Colony I has some public transit, including 3 transit stops within 30.8 miles. Transit options include Milwaukee and General Mitchell Intl. Airport Amtrak Station.

Parks and Recreation

Recreational activities near Bay Colony I are plentiful. Discover 4 parks within 4.6 miles, including Lincoln Park - Glendale, Urban Ecology Center-Riverside Park, and Kletzsch Park.

Airports

Living in Shorewood/Whitefish Bay provides easy access to General Mitchell International, located just 25 minutes from Bay Colony I.

Local Education

Primary and Secondary Schools

GreatSchools rating: 2 out of 10

Marvin Pratt Elementary School

Grades PK-5

Public

GreatSchools rating: 10 out of 10

Cumberland Elementary School

Grades PK-5

Public

Not rated

North Shore Montessori School

Grades PK-5

Private

GreatSchools rating: 10 out of 10

Whitefish Bay Middle School

Grades 6-8

Public

Not rated

Holy Family Parish School

Grades PK-8

Private

GreatSchools rating: 10 out of 10

Whitefish Bay High

Grades 9-12

Public

Not rated

Dominican High School

Grades 9-12

Private

Data provided by GreatSchools.org © 2026. All rights reserved.

GreatSchools

Colleges and Universities

School Commute Time (Distance)
Cardinal Stritch University Drive: 9 min (2.9 mi)
Univ of Wisc., Milwaukee Drive: 8 min (3 mi)
Milwaukee Tech., Downtown Drive: 12 min (5.4 mi)
Milwaukee Sch. of Engineering Drive: 13 min (5.9 mi)

About Bay Colony I

This Whitefish Bay Property offers townhomes, and 2-bedroom apartments close to shopping and local activities.

Bay Colony I is an apartment community in Whitefish Bay, WI

Contact

Property Address:
189 E Fairmount Ave,
Whitefish Bay, WI 53217
Phone Number: (414) 270-1365
More Information:
View Property Website
Office Hours
  • Sunday Closed
  • Monday By Appointment Only
  • Tuesday By Appointment Only
  • Wednesday By Appointment Only
  • Thursday By Appointment Only
  • Friday By Appointment Only
  • Saturday Closed

Avoid Scams

Protect yourself from fraud. Do not send money to anyone you don't know.

Avoid Scams

Renter Reviews

For Bay Colony I

1.0

1 Rating & Review

  • 11/29/21

    Terrible Property Manager and Maintenance

    Avoid this place at all costs. The property manager is non existent and the maintenance people are slow, rude and cut corners any chance they get. Units have been without heat for over 6 weeks and it is now approaching December!

    Nothing that needs to be fixed is every fixed with urgency

    They have cut corners by providing heaters however if more than 2 are plugged in it breaks the electrical circuit and all of your power goes out. People come to whitefish bay for safety and a better standard
    … of living and living here has essentially been like living in the slums!

    Review from Apartments.com

    1 Person Found This Helpful