Apartments for Rent in Bay Shore, NY

Bay Shore, located on the South Shore of Long Island, offers apartments for rent in a community rich with maritime heritage dating back to 1708 when the land was purchased from the Secatogue Native Americans. Today, this waterfront hamlet serves as a gateway to Fire Island, featuring a restored Main Street and historic architecture.

Renters in Bay Shore find a mix of boutique apartment communities and single-family homes, with average rents ranging from $2,500 for one-bedroom units to $4,100 for three-bedroom properties. The revitalized downtown area features restaurants, clothing boutiques, and specialty shops, all within walking distance of the Long Island Rail Road station that provides direct service to New York City. The Bay Shore Marina and Great South Bay offer water views and recreational activities along the coast.

Bay Shore's location provides transportation options with the Southern State Parkway forming its northern boundary and the LIRR offering regular service to Manhattan. Located approximately 42 miles from New York City, the hamlet is home to major employers including South Shore University Hospital. The median household income is $96,100.