Apartments for Rent in Whitefish Bay, WI

Whitefish Bay sits along the shores of Lake Michigan just north of Milwaukee, offering a beautiful lakeside setting with a storied past. Once home to the popular Pabst Resort that attracted thousands of weekend visitors in the late 1800s, this community has grown into a vibrant Milwaukee County suburb. The eastern section developed as part of the area's "gold coast," featuring architecturally notable homes along the lakeshore.

Renters in Whitefish Bay enjoy access to numerous amenities in a compact, walkable setting. The village spans just over two square miles, creating an intimate community where boutique apartment buildings and well-maintained rental homes predominate. The rental market features a range of options from updated apartments averaging $1,640 for one-bedroom units to spacious single-family homes. The area's tree-lined streets, well-maintained parks like Klode Park and Big Bay Park, and proximity to Lake Michigan create an inviting atmosphere.

The community is home to Whitefish Bay High School, which consistently ranks among Wisconsin's top academic performers. Silver Spring Drive serves as the village's main commercial corridor, featuring locally-owned shops, cafes, and restaurants. Commuters appreciate the convenient location just minutes from downtown Milwaukee, while the village's waterfront parks and Lake Michigan shoreline provide year-round recreational opportunities. With its blend of historical architecture, community amenities, and lakeside location, Whitefish Bay offers renters a welcoming neighborhood rich in local history.