Apartments for Rent in Lancaster, NY

Lancaster, NY is home to the oldest stone structure in Erie County — the historic Warren Hull House built in 1810. Located just 14 miles east of downtown Buffalo, this suburban community combines its rich heritage with a thriving present-day atmosphere. The town spans nearly 38 square miles, providing ample space for a variety of rental options from boutique apartment communities to single-family homes.

Renters in Lancaster enjoy access to several well-maintained parks and recreational areas. Como Lake Park features scenic trails and picturesque views along Cayuga Creek, while the Lancaster Heritage Trail offers four miles of paved paths for cycling or walking. The town's convenient location near major highways, including Interstate 90 and Route 33, makes commuting to Buffalo and surrounding areas straightforward, typically taking less than 30 minutes. With a median household income of approximately $82,000, Lancaster provides comfortable living spaces within a welcoming community atmosphere.

Lancaster's rental market includes a mix of apartment communities and private homes, with average one-bedroom rents around $1,489 per month. The town is divided into several distinct areas, including the historic village center with its preserved 19th-century architecture along Central Avenue, and more recently developed neighborhoods in the southern and eastern sections. Neighborhoods near Transit Road offer proximity to shopping and dining options, while areas near Como Lake Park provide a more serene setting. The nearby villages of Depew and Bowmansville expand rental possibilities while maintaining easy access to Lancaster's amenities.