
Filter Your Search
All Filters
Rent Range
-Situated on Long Island's South Shore, Sayville serves as a gateway to Fire Island with ferry services to popular destinations like Cherry Grove and Fire Island Pines. This historic hamlet, dating back to 1761, offers a perfect blend of coastal charm and small-town atmosphere that earned it recognition as the "friendliest town in America" in 1994. With tree-lined streets and a walkable downtown area along Main Street, Sayville provides an appealing setting for residents.
Rental options in Sayville include an array of properties, with an average one-bedroom apartment renting for approximately $2,400 monthly. The housing landscape features well-maintained townhomes, apartment communities, and single-family rental homes with architectural character. The area combines proximity to the Great South Bay while maintaining convenient access to metropolitan amenities. Downtown Sayville offers a collection of independent shops, restaurants, and cafés within walking distance of many residential areas.
Transportation options make Sayville practical for commuters, with the Long Island Rail Road station providing service to Manhattan and connections to local ferries. Suffolk County Transit also offers bus service via Montauk Highway. For those who drive, Sunrise Highway provides easy access to neighboring communities and employment centers. Nearby natural attractions include the Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge and Sunken Forest, offering outdoor recreation opportunities that complement the area's coastal setting and mature tree canopy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Average Rent Rates
What's the average rent for an apartment in Sayville, NY?
Apartment averages in Sayville, NY varies based on size.
- $2,404 for a 1-bedroom apartment in Sayville, NY
- $2,971 for a 2-bedroom apartment in Sayville, NY
- $3,925 for a 3-bedroom apartment in Sayville, NY
Rental Requirements
Can I find a short-term apartment in Sayville, NY?
There are 8 short-term apartments in Sayville, NY.
Transportation
How do people usually get around Sayville, NY?
Sayville, NY is easy to get around by walking. It's easy to run errands or explore the area on foot.
Education
What colleges and universities are in Sayville, NY?
If you’re a college or university student moving to Sayville, NY, ForRent.com can help you find a rental near St Joseph's Coll. Long Island-Long Island Campus, Touro University-Law Center, SUNY Suffolk Co. Ammerman-Ammerman Campus and others.
Find More Apartments for Rent in Sayville, NY
Other Type of Rentals
Sayville Apartments by Amenity
- Pet-Friendly Apartments in Sayville
- Waterfront Apartments in Sayville
- Apartments with a Pool in Sayville
- Apartments with Wheelchair Access in Sayville
- Apartments with Washer & Dryer in Sayville
- Apartments with Utilities Included in Sayville
- Apartments with a Garage in Sayville
- Apartments with a Virtual Tour in Sayville
Apartment Specialties
Apartments in your Budget
Find Rentals Near Sayville, NY
For Rent near Sayville
- Apartments in West Sayville
- Apartments in Bayport
- Apartments in Fire Island Pines
- Apartments in Cherry Grove
- Apartments in Oakdale
- Apartments in Bohemia
- Apartments in Blue Point
- Apartments in Patchogue
- Apartments in Holbrook
- Houses for Rent in Oakdale
- Houses for Rent in Bohemia
- Houses for Rent in Patchogue
- Houses for Rent in Holbrook
Sayville Neighborhoods with Apartments
- Apartments for Rent in The Woods at Sayville
- Apartments for Rent in Fairfield Sunrise Gardens
- Apartments for Rent in Regency Knolls
- Apartments for Rent in Idle Hour Colony
- Apartments for Rent in Riviera Park
- Apartments for Rent in Westbridge Estates
- Apartments for Rent in Sayville Heights
- Apartments for Rent in Central Suffolk
- Apartments for Rent in Southwestern Suffolk
- Apartments for Rent in Western Suffolk
- Apartments for Rent in Cypress Gardens Oakdale






























